In New Jersey, residents who call the police for assistance may wonder if this gives officers the right to enter their homes. The answer is, generally, no because the Fourth Amendment prohibits it.
When can police enter without a warrant?
There are a few key situations which provide exceptions to the warrant requirement. One of the most common is consent: If a homeowner or even an occupant explicitly allows the police to enter, officers can do so without a warrant.
Another common excuse to enter that is often held up later in court is “exigent circumstances.” Under this exception, police can enter without a warrant if there is an immediate danger to life or property, such as during an emergency when they hear calls for help or see a fire.
Another common excuse to enter your home that is held up in court later is known as the “plain view doctrine.” If officers see illegal items or activities clearly from outside, they may enter without a warrant to prevent the destruction of evidence.
Also, if officers are chasing a suspect who enters a home, they can follow without needing a warrant.
Can I refuse entry to the police when they arrive?
This is a situation that is much more common than people realize: You call the police for help, but suddenly, they are trying to enter your home or treating you like a criminal. You started the interaction with one problem, but now you have two problems. Can you just refuse?
As a resident, you have the right to refuse entry to the police if they do not have a warrant or a valid exception does not apply. It is important to communicate your refusal clearly and respectfully, such as saying, “I do not consent to your entry.” This statement helps protect your rights and makes your stance clear.
Consequences of refusing entry
Unfortunately, just because you are lawfully exercising your rights and the police may, in fact, be in the wrong, does not mean that there will not be consequences to your actions. Refusing entry to police when they lack a warrant, or a legal exception should generally have no negative legal repercussions.
Should the police enter your home without proper cause, any evidence they obtain should be inadmissible in court, as it would be considered the result of an illegal search. You may also have a civil case for their unlawful breach of your constitutional rights. But, your goal throughout the unlawful encounter should be to deescalate and document. You cannot yell or argue your way out of the situation.